“I am a mother.” I read those words, and I hear them over and over again. Before Ellie (shorthand maybe should be B.E?), I never really thought twice about them. But now I “am” a mother, the question of what that statement actually weighs resounds in my skull, like a bowling ball ricocheting down the aisle (bowling ball analogies are on my mind, now that my baby is starting to feel as heavy as one).
I don’t think in terms of “I am a mother.” I think more in terms of one of my new functions or roles as mothering, or parenting. It’s like saying “I am an arts researcher,” or “I am a writer.” I am not either of those things – I do those things. Similarly, I do mothering – that does not make me a label.
I don’t mean to offend anyone here. I know that being a mother is an incredible responsibility and task and job and life choice. It just confounded me to think in terms of this new name for who I am.
Perhaps it is a cultural evolution – we Gen X and Yers refuse to be defined by our roles, but prefer to think of ourselves as individuals, functioning in different ways in different settings. We like to think of ourselves as having something fundamental at the core of all our fleeting journeys – a sort of modern, ego-based Western take on the Hindu “atman,” the constant consciousness that underpins all else.
That said, I think it has always been a gender thing too. My husband is a “father,” but he pointed out that society does not define him by that, but rather more by his job.
When I had Ellie, I had a crisis. I really do think of having a baby in those terms, even though it sounds melodramatic, but really it is just a definitional issue. Not all crises are bad, but they are nevertheless major events which change everything. That was Ellie.
As a woman in her 30s, I long had the reins over my day. I knew when I was going to eat, how long I would have to sleep for, what I was going to do. I had a sure sense of myself as a writer, a well respected policy consultant, an good friend, a kind wife, an interesting individual worth getting to know.
And then Ellie came. Suddenly, I did not know myself. Part of that may have been the intense sleep deprivation of the first couple of weeks, which made me feel a little crazy (another story for another post). My identity had fundamentally shifted, and I didn’t know where to.
After the third day at home with Ellie, I spoke to my husband. I had always thought I would take a year off and be with the baby. I had always thought I would relish that year off, and I still may. But I had to say some things out loud, things I wasn’t sure it was OK to say as a mother – but there they were.
“I am not sure this full-time mothering is for me. I have realised something about myself, and that is if I am only doing one thing, I tend to obsess about it. I need more than one focus. I may want to go back to some part-time work in a few months.”
It was hard to admit that I may not be cut out for full-time mothering. It’s not that I don’t love my baby. It’s not that I don’t enjoy her. But I also enjoy my mind. I had long drawn (partly unbeknownst to me) a lot of my identity from what I did. Like a doctor from the 1950s, I had become what I did and now that I didn’t do it any more, I was at sea. Maybe for me, the Gen-X/Gen-Y evolution really just meant that women as well as men are now defined by their work, and now that I wasn’t, I didn’t know where to draw my sense of self any more.
I think it was more than that, though. It was deeper – it went further than changing my idea of myself from worker/breadwinner to mother/carer. It was taking on the responsibility of a whole, separate life, one I would now have to care for, for the rest of mine. In practical terms, that meant a vast portion of the time I used to have completely at my own disposal would now be dedicated to another individual’s needs and activities. For now that meant her sleeping and feeding. In a few years it will mean her soccer and playgroups, doctors and schools, camps, and eventually her own life crises, which I hope to be there for. In identity terms, that meant working out who I was in that bigger picture of our lives together, with my new job as mother.
I thought I had been ready to give up my time. I had had my fill of time to myself, and being selfish ( in the sense that I had only my own self to think about). I was ready to give. But when Ellie came along, the reality of the hours and energy that would take came home to me and I guess I quietly freaked out.
Now that I am getting more sleep (we have devised a night shift system which makes me feel guilty but better rested – I said to my husband yesterday, “I’m still exhausted, but I think I am nicer to be around,” to which he assented), and some time has passed, the crisis is settling into a life shift, as all crises do. I am getting used to my new role, and the new pattern to my days (which is basically, do what the baby wants to do). I am writing tentatively, here again, which helps my brain. And I am still thinking and pondering because how could I not? In short, I have started to assimilate my new role as mother into my other roles as thinker, feeler, ponderer, wonderer, reader, writer, lover, political unit of democracy, tax payer, friend.
I would really like to know what other women have thought about this topic. I know so many other smart, do-ing women who have had babies and who must have some fascinating insights for me and others on the shift in identity and how they manage it daily. What happened in your minds (and bodies) when you became mothers? How did you “become” a mother?
For me, I “became” a mother, when I finally accepted that my life was no longer wholly under my control. The majority of my existence is now dictated by the wants and needs of my little people. Giving in to the reality of loss of freedom and the things that once (completely) defined my existence was really hard and I resisted that idea for a long time. Those things haven’t completely gone away and will hopefully be resurrected, but for now they have to wait. I still get excited planning the things I want to do, but I can no accept that these things will now have a couple of hours a week dedicated to them, probably in the early hours of the morning, rather than the time that I would actually like to spend on them. I also now think “Can’t wait to do that! – In 5 years time”.
Everything now revolves around people other than me. That’s OK. I do want it that way. But it sure is hard.
For me, accepting that now I am somewhat defined as a “mother”, particularly because I am not working anymore was difficult to swallow. What I HATED, absolutely hated – was OTHER people defining me by my new role. Particularly the older generation who never expected their partners to return to work after having children. I would feel miserable whenever anyone started a sentence with “Well, you’re a mother now …” It was a complete loss of identity and I hated that suddenly people no longer respected my intelligence, abilities or achievements and could only see that I had reproduced. Almost 3 years later I’m happy with this title and proud of it, but I felt that people did not value me anymore. They were probably in reality honouring the sacrifice that women make in having babies and it was more ME feeling that I had lost worth. Through the sleep deprived haze, relentless exhaustion, stress and resulting inability to think straight I did feel that “Catherine” no longer existed. I’m still in here, waiting, and I can now see that one day I’ll get to do a small amount of the things that I want to do.
I can see why friends vanish when they breed. They no longer have the time nor energy to do anything else. It’s a constant struggle for most people. From what I’ve heard, daycare helps a lot. Talking to other parents helps a lot too, realising that everyone is actually going through the same things. It’s just you didn’t really GET IT before…
Mother is now my job title and I aim to do it well. The job description will expand more fully with time but I’ll now always think of myself as a mother.
Thanks Catherine. I have re-read your response a few times now, taking it in. Thanks for being so honest about how it has really been.
I think when a woman thinks about having kids – well, it was like this for me anyway – I wasn’t really aware that what I was embarking on was a total, forever life change. When you decide to have kids, you decide to completely and irrevocably change your life. In practical terms, that means cutting the hours you have to do your usual things drastically, as you say – almost to nothing. But claiming some of that time again as the kids get older is an important thing to do – and until then, ten minutes on the balcony or half an hour walk when Yen is at home – half an hour, alone, not needed by anyone! Who knew what a luxury that would be! It’s amazing to me how adaptable we truly are.
“It was a complete loss of identity and I hated that suddenly people no longer respected my intelligence, abilities or achievements and could only see that I had reproduced. ” – I think this is what really got me in the first month or so – the sense that my actual identity had changed somehow, and that this is somehow now what I “was,” not just another thing that I “did.” So strange after for so long taking for granted the multiple parts that make up the whole of me and that others would see that too.